7 Comments »

Suprised (and a bit alarmed) to read the other day that Highland Council’s Education Department is blocking blogs and other such web 2.0 sites through its Websense filtering system.

Not surprised that a council is blocking such sites, (many other Scottish councils use Websense as their filtering mechanism) but more surprised that it was blocking my own site.

When I started keeping a blog, I used blogger.com and deployed frames on my site to incorporate it for visitors into my wider website. After a bit of thought, I realised it would be better to host the blog element myself and stop this part of my site being blocked by filtering systems.

All well and good I thought, until the other day, with the revelation about websense. Obviously (or hopefully!) this is blocking by content, rather than domain?

What a shame, and what a missed opportunity. Not just in blocking my site, but by blocking the numerous other bloggers out there in education – engaged in meaningful professional dialogue and development.

Don’t think I’m getting at Highland here – I’ve always found Highland to be luminaries in education. My point rather is this – many councils employ filtering technology. BUT… did you know you can request that sites are ‘unblocked’? Most councils wil have in place a system that  allows users to request that sites be freed up to be viewed. If you hear of situations where educationally valid sites are being blocked by a filter, get in touch with the people that run the filter locally – they may just be able to change things for you :-)

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post Post to Delicious Delicious

7 Responses to “Websense says no…”
 

It’s true that requests can be made for sites to be unblocked and these requests are usually dealt with very quickly. However, if a teacher prepares work at home in the evenings it then requires a ‘double check’ runthrough in school to check that all’s OK – most teachers just don’t feel they have time for this. If all doesn’t work out well then there’s a tendency for them just to give up through frustration – that’s what many of them tell me anyway. Suddenly experiencing such a high level of filtering has certainly frustrated me.

Alan Stewart wrote on May 2nd, 2008 at 6:50 am

 

Hi AB.

East Lothian just went through an automatic server update. It ended up blocking all typepad and blogspot.com sites. Even Ollie Bray’s site was blocked LOL! :P

However I spoke nicely to IT who were very understanding and relaxed the firewall for those demains.

:-)

Tess Watson wrote on May 2nd, 2008 at 2:03 pm

 

Hi Andrew

Great to meet up with you yesterday.

Dundee also uses Websense. Websense classes everything not on its white list or black list as uncategorised and automatically blocks all of them. But as you say, they can be unblocked fairly readily for valid educational reasons. Unfortunately some people don’t think it is worth the bother and so opportunities are missed. :(

Bob Hill wrote on May 2nd, 2008 at 5:04 pm

 

Its much the same in your old stamping ground of Argyll & Bute – as I mentioned in my blog when we moved to the new building.

Websense has recently been cranked up to ‘paranoid’ meaning we couldn’t access SCHOLAR, any University entrance related sites or even the school’s own online resource site – http://www.getintohabit.co.uk

I’m a firm advocate of instilling responsibility in employees. Staff should be allowed free reign over the content available, on the understanding that clear policies and sanctions exist. If a teacher is deliberately looking at inappropriate material then they should be disciplined or even dismissed.

I’d love to be able to show youtube clips in my teaching, play appropriate educational ‘games’ and indulge in a bit of Web 2.0 – type stuff, but as Alan stated the double handling at home and school makes it too much hassle.

Drew wrote on May 2nd, 2008 at 8:30 pm

 

I’d be glad to chat to you further about this, I’m piloting edublogging as a member of The Highland Council, I can access my blog fine through the system, it has been barred at all. Though some of the streaming and clips won’t work. Edublogs.com hasn’t been barred.

There is an E-Safety steering group in Highland set up to look at both Internet Safety and Responsible Use, Jim H and I will be looking to get blogging sites lifted at some point. I just want to make it clear that the council is not opposed to staff having their own blog. Happy to chat further, give me a call or email, I’m on the outlook. Louise

Louise Jones wrote on May 3rd, 2008 at 7:33 am

 

Alan’s point is well made. It’s very frustrating.
Also there is a number of teachers who will only take steps forward at school where you are physically there to “rescue” them if necessary. So there is no opportunity to encourage these teachers to explore blogs. Even if you get some specific ones unblocked, the whole exciting, serendipitous nature of following links from one blog to another is lost.

Dorothy Coe wrote on May 3rd, 2008 at 3:29 pm

 

[...] to access some blogging sites but had them restricted by the web filtering software Websense. Andrew sympathised about the problems that sometimes surrounds filtering in schools and made the [...]

Highland and Websense. « Jim Henderson’s Blog wrote on May 4th, 2008 at 11:38 am

Leave a Reply